Friday, January 01, 2010

The One True Best Movies of the Decade List (11-20)

So we move down our list to numbers 11-20. A couple brief proviso's though:

1) The Ebert Principle

When looking at a great indie film or a great mainstream film, the indie film is to be preferred.

Heavy preference will be given to arthouse movies now that we're out of the top ten. One thing I always hate in these kind of lists is that they always name a bunch of movies I've already seen, and don't need anyone to tell me were great. Movies like 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days that score highly on Metacritic and aren't seen by most people are such exceptions, so the great indie flicks that aren't exceptions are getting their air time here.

If you're wondering why I'm calling this the Ebert Principle, take a look at Ebert's blog sometime. Guy can't say a bad word about an arthouse film. Even if it's a bad arthouse film.

2) I'll do my best to avoid indulgences

The nostalgia train for The Wackness being probably the biggest exception to this. I loved Star Wars Episode III because, well, I love Star Wars, not because it was a great film in the sense that Un Proph├ęte was.

Don't like the arrangement? My list. My rules. It's good to be king!

11) Man on Wire

Wow. This guy is seriously insane. "If I die, what a beautiful death!"

12) March of the Penguins

No real story. Nothing truly stunning about the cinematography. All they do is survive. And that's enough.

13) Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.

Jim Carrey and Kate Winslet both give solid performances in what was the most philosophically profound movie of the decade.

14) Chop Shop

Ramin Bahrani is the best director you've never heard of. A powerful story not because of the emotions it evokes (though those help), but because of the verisimillitude. Bahrani painstakingly researched his subject matter. As hard as it might be to fathom, this is real.

15) Hard Candy

A stronger finish and this would have easily made the top ten. It seems clear that the filmmaker lost his nerve (perhaps fearing an NC-17?), and decided it would be better to lower a god with ropes. We all know how it should have ended.

16) Memento

You almost have to watch it twice to catch this complex story. Brilliantly crafted, like the story's protagonist, you never know what has already happened.

17) Persepolis

Animated coming of age story? Really? My skepticism was increased by the story's setting in Iran, where I feared it might fall prey to political correctness or a crusade. It did neither.

18) Batoru rowaiaru (Battle Royale)

Lord of the Flies in futuristic Japan. The game is brutal, the winner unexpected, the story compelling. Suspension of disbelief is well-rewarded.

19) Das weisse Band (The White Ribbon)

Big year at Cannes in 2009, with four Palme d'Or nominees making the best of decade cut. The second entry, The White Ribbon, took home the Golden Palm. It shouldn't have, Un Proph├ęte was head and shoulders above it, but it's a masterpiece nonetheless. While the rise of Naziism is the obvious context, the film's subtext extends far beyond that.

20) Gaau ji (Dumplings)

Fruit Chan's horror on the lengths we go to to serve vanity. A horror in the Edgar Allan Poe sense of the term. Do yourself a favour, watch the short on Three Extremes, don't trouble yourself with the feature length offering, which is just the short with a lot of filler.

3 comments:

Stephen C. Carlson said...

16? Well, somewhat higher than Loren's ranking. I'll have to take what I can get.

Loren Rosson III said...

Nice slot for Hard Candy. :) And you're right: the filmmaker didn't have the balls he left Jeff Kohlver. They should have come off Jeff, and the director should have grown a pair. But the first 3/4 of the film is flawless.

Rick Sumner said...

Sorry Stephen, don't take it too hard though, those are some great movies ahead of it.

I think the NC-17 rating is probably what did it for him, Loren. I can't think of anything else that would make it fall apart like that. Until then they had you on the edge of your seat, scared to breathe lest you miss another word. And that had you like that by spending 90% of the time sitting in chairs talking. No small feat.

This was easily the toughest ten to come up with. . .no matter what I do great films that should never have the phrase "bottom half" associated with them end up there.